Are Cloth Diapers More Eco-Friendly?
February 2nd, 2012Even parents who choose to use disposable diapers for reasons of convenience would probably agree on first thought that cloth diapers are more eco-friendly. It just seems like common sense: reusable is better for Mother Earth than single-use. The disposable diaper industry however, is fighting back.
Studies commissioned by disposable diaper manufacturers in the 1990s indicated that in the long run, disposable diapers were actually better for the environment. The manufacturers claimed that cloth diapering required such great amounts of water and electricity that the carbon footprint was larger than that of disposable diapering.
Do Cloth Diapers Harm the Environment More Than Disposables?
If you’re wavering between disposable diapers and cloth diapers, you probably want to know if there’s any truth to these claims. Does cloth diapering harm the environment? The answer is yes – to an extent. Cloth diapers do require extra water and electricity. But that doesn’t mean that the alternative – disposable diapers – is less harmful.
The studies completed in the early 1990s didn’t take into account the harmful chemicals released during the production of disposable diapers or from the discarded diapers themselves. For example, according to a more recent study, toluene, xylene, ethylbenzene, styrene, and isopropylbenzene are just a few of the chemicals released into the earth from disposable diapers.
Unless you’re a toxicologist, the chemicals named above may not mean much to you. But you’ve probably heard the term dioxin, which refers to a class of chemical compounds, rather than a single chemical. Dioxins are listed by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) as being extremely toxic, and have been shown to cause cancer.
They are produced as by-products of the bleaching process needed to produce bright white diapers. Whatever effect cloth diapers may have on the environment, it’s certain that they don’t leech toxic chemicals into tile earth or into your baby’s skin. Also, cloth diapering doesn’t put excrement in landfills where it can contaminate ground water and spread disease.
Use Common Sense When Choosing Between Disposables and Cloth Diapers
There’s a wonderful quote from Paula DeVore on the non-profit organization Green America’s website. DeVore runs an organic cotton cloth diaper company named Babyworks, and has been vocal in the controversy between disposable and cloth diapers. She asks if reusable diapers do the same damage to the environment, why hasn’t it been proven that other reusable products, like dishes, do the same (ceramic vs paper dishes, for example).
Why, indeed? Despite all the contradictory information flying around, perhaps the most useful source for parents is common sense. Of course, cloth diapering affects the environment somewhat – but what doesn’t? Learn how to launder and reuse cloth diapers properly, and Mother Earth will thank you. Cloth diapering seems like common sense because it is.